Every Monday morning, Logan Hill and Sloane Crosley have been offering their post-âMad Menâ analysis. Ms. Crosley is traveling, but read on for Mr. Hillâs take and then in the comments tell us what you think about Donâs rash decision, Joanâs outburst, Peteâs pratfall and Peggyâs predicament.
Iâve been a grump about âMad Menâ lately, but this week, the show was at its very best.
The latest episodes have been rolling out in the middle of the NBA playoffs, and, as a fan of both basketball and quality prestige television, Iâve had a hard time separating the two. This season, âMad Men,â filmed in Los Angeles, has often felt like the Lakers: A storied franchise, stocked with great players (Jon Hamm, Elisabeth Moss, John Slattery, Vincent Kartheiser, Christina Hendricks) and led by a world-class coach (Matthew Weiner), the team was floundering without direction and a wonky game plan that just wasnât working. Resting on its laurels, the show seemed to overvalue historical footnotes and period-perfect art-direction instead of risky, actor-driven drama.
Last week, âMad Menâ bottomed out. The King assassination episode devolved into a âWe Didnât Start the Fireâ grab bag of references to everything from Marx to the Second Avenue subway, the gentrification of the Upper West and Upper East Sides, Paul Newman, Tecumseh, Eugene McCarthy and âThe Planet of the Apes.â That poorly directed, diffuse episode made mere montage of tragedy and boiled over into a âLord of the Ringsâ-style series of portentous endings and loose ends. We got too much of everything but what the show does best: American business.
This weekâs beautifully written episode plays to the showâs strengths â" the actors â" and the business of advertising. Suddenly, its lead performers seem to know why theyâre on-screen.
Roger practically bounds off the bench, ready for action, and he has rarely been better: The aging, insecure accounts man beds a stewardess to mine her for information (even using his dead mother as a come-on) and it works. In the first-class lounge, he scores an audition with Chevy, rubs it in Peteâs outraged face, and turns the firm on its nose. âGood idea,â says the Chevy man. âIâm full of them,â says a water-sipping Roger. And heâs right. Much of this season has been moribund, but Roger shakes it awake.
Don, meanwhile, is a powerful jerk again and the show is better for it. When he hands Herb, the Jaguar man, a business card and tells him itâs âthe name of the guy whoâs going to be handling your account from now on,â itâs thrillingly brutal. Itâs no wonder that Don seduces Megan when he goes home, because, as Pete says, itâs never been about the money for Don. Itâs always been about power, about momentum. For six seasons, Donâs animating force has been mojo â" that commingling sense of amassing power â" and this is the first episode this season that shows him grappling with it. Even when Joan calls him out for his narcissism, Don pushes right back, focused on his push for power â" right or wrong â" because thatâs what has motivated him for six seasons. This week, when heâs wrong it feels so right.
Pete sees his father-in-law at a Manhattan whorehouse with the âbiggest, blackest prostitute youâve ever seenâ (Sketchy Bob from the agency offers to pay for Peteâs assignation. What is he, some corporate spy? Some government mole?). Pete also complains to Trudy, who wonât sleep with him, that he doesnât understand why she maintains âevery other aspect of this marriage except the one that matters.â He pratfalls down the stairs, loses his account, is degraded by his hypocritical father-in-law, and is otherwise unmasked as the sputtering impotent cretin we know and somehow love to hate. Forget Bizarro Pete taking offense at Harryâs racism for unclear familial reasons: The old nasty Pete is back.
Meanwhile, Peggy rushes into the future, moving into her new apartment on the horrific Upper West Side, negotiating with Abe, kissing her boss, and fantasizing about making out with her boss while kissing Abe. The primary dramatic struggle of Season 6 has been that Peggy was pushed offstage at the end of Season 5. When the showâs most sympathetic character left Sterling Cooper Draper Pryce, it felt like the oxygen was sucked out of the building. So who cares that this newly merged company, made up of Peggyâs old and new agencies, is tackling an ugly car (the Chevy Nova)? Thanks to the merger, the showâs most vital character is suddenly thrust into the center of a work-love triangle.
The first batch of episodes has felt like a Cliffâs Notes for the era. This episode is still mirroring the times; itâs just not explaining its metaphors every two minutes in overt dialogue. And it gave fans plenty to love: Peteâs spill down the stairs, Joanâs outrageous dresses, Megan in Cleopatra regalia, actual pleasurable sex, Abeâs anachronistic musculature (Dude looks positively CrossFit), and the return of Trudyâs insane nightwear. Surely, this all could have been accomplished much sooner, but now this uneven season seems like it might be righted: Coach Weiner has thrown the rock to his bigs â" Roger, Don, Pete, and Peggy â" in an episode that reminds us that this series (which has never been terribly brilliant about civil rights or the Vietnam war) is often a thrilling, hilarious document of how American creative business got big, and at what cost.
âThis business is rigged,â Don laments at the bar. Yes, it is. But how? That is the showâs sick thrill.
Logan Hill is a journalist who has contributed to The New York Times, New York, GQ, Rolling Stone, Wired and others.