Total Pageviews

The Ad Campaign: Far Behind, Lhota Takes a Risk

First aired: October 16, 2013
Produced by: Wilson Grand Communications
Issue: Joseph J. Lhota

Confronting stagnant poll numbers and a lackluster debate performance, Joseph J. Lhota, the Republican nominee for mayor, is hoping an aggressive new advertisement can refocus the race on an issue that Republicans typically dominate: public safety.

“Can’t Go Back,” which began being broadcast on Wednesday, is Mr. Lhota’s third commercial of the general election campaign, and by far the sharpest attack yet on his Democratic opponent, Bill de Blasio.

Fact-Check
0:01
“Bill de Blasio voted to take over 5,000 cops off our streets.”

It is true that Mr. de Blasio, as a councilman, voted in favor of budgets proposed by Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg that led to a reduction of the Police Department’s work force. Mr. de Blasio did not personally propose those cuts, and the vast majority of City Council members also approved the city budgets, whose particulars were negotiated long before the floor vote.

0:05
“And de Blasio’s response to violent biker gangs? Visit motorcycle clubs and talk to bikers.”

Mr. de Blasio did suggest in an interview after the motorcycle episode that police officers be proactive by informing motorcycle groups of a zero-tolerance policy for dangerous behavior. But he has also said that violent motorcyclists should be punished for any criminality.

0:13
“Bill de Blasio’s recklessly dangerous agenda on crime will take us back to this.”

The ad does not explain what would be reckless or dangerous about Mr. de Blasio’s policing views, nor does it make clear how the Democrat would prompt a return to decline and decay.

Scorecard

The visual equivalent of hyperventilating, this ad relies on a jarring and ultimately unexplained connection between Mr. de Blasio’s liberalism and frightening episodes in the city’s history, like the Crown Heights race riot.

It is a provocative and risky move for Mr. Lhota, but with three weeks to Election Day and a 50-point deficit in the polls, the Republican needs to take a risk.

The ad will earn headlines, but it could also turn off voters who see its message as too negative, or simply nonsensical.


@import url(http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/css/newsgraphics/2013/0712-nyc-ad-campaign/promo.css);



Catching, and Releasing, Monarchs as They Flutter Down to Mexico

Tim Walsh holding a monarch butterfly in Riverside Park that he was tagging as part of a conservation project.Corey Kilgannon/The New York Times Tim Walsh holding a monarch butterfly in Riverside Park that he was tagging as part of a conservation project.

Tim Walsh, 67, saw the fluttering orange and black wings on Tuesday afternoon among the flowers near the Riverside Park tennis courts, around 96th Street on the West Side of Manhattan.

“This is the latest in the season I’ve ever seen one here,” said Mr. Walsh after deftly scooping the monarch butterfly into his net. “They’re usually not around after Columbus Day.”

He gently pulled the butterfly out, and from a small kit that he had stuffed in his backpack he peeled off a tag â€" an adhesive disk smaller than a dime bearing contact information in tiny lettering â€" and gently pressed it onto the butterfly’s right rear wing.

For years, in September and early October, Mr. Walsh, who lives near the park on West 93rd Street, has been prowling this area, which he calls a favorite stopover spot for monarch butterflies during their long migration every year between Canada and Mexico.

“My theory is that they float down along the Hudson River, and the conditions are ideal today: warm with a gentle wind out of the north,” he said.

“They come down when they smell the flowers here,” he said, pointing out the purple-flowered butterfly bushes as well as the milkweed - a main source of food for monarchs â€" near the courts.

Mr. Walsh has always stood in wonder of the monarchs’ annual multigenerational migration, fluttering on the air currents for thousands of miles, Canada to Mexico and back. He marvels at how they mysteriously seem to find the route, by the millions, to specific forest spots in the mountains of central Mexico, where they survive the winter by roosting together.

“It takes four generations to complete the round trip,” Mr. Walsh said. In Mexico, the butterflies are a major tourist attraction, even as their numbers have dwindled in recent years as a result of extreme weather and a decline in milkweed.

“I used to be an avid fisherman but I get a lot more pleasure out of this,” said Mr. Walsh, who six years ago, became a volunteer tagger for Monarch Watch, a program based at the University of Kansas that relies on butterfly lovers across the country to catch, tag and release monarchs in order to gather migratory information.

Mr. Walsh submits a detailed list of the butterflies he has tagged and hopes that the tags - each has an individual code and a Web site address and a phone number â€" will be found in Mexico.

“They spread the word in those regions that they’ll pay five bucks for each tag that’s turned in,” he said. “Five bucks, in that part of Mexico, goes a long way.”

Mr. Walsh, an avid painter and fluent Spanish-speaker who teaches language teachers, said, “Years ago, when I was teaching English in Guadalajara, I painted a mural of monarchs flying over the curvature of the earth with no borders.”

“It said, in Spanish, ‘Art, like the monarch butterfly, knows neither boundaries nor nationalities.’”

Mr. Walsh said he had a 1967 Volvo station wagon with 230,000 miles on it, “and my dream is to, one day, paint some butterflies on it and go on the road following the migration.”

As he held the butterfly on Tuesday - the 17th monarch he has tagged this season and the only one he has spotted in the past week - he said, “You hold it by its thorax, for its strength, and by the front of their wings with its wings closed.”

“Sometimes people get very hostile, and say ‘What are you doing to those little butterflies?’” he said. “I have to explain I’m not bothering them in any way.”

“This one was probably up in Tarrytown this morning,” he said, making sure the sticker was firmly affixed. Then he let the butterfly go, and it drifted up into the breeze and over the tennis courts.

“I love that - whenever you let them go, they always fly south,” he said.



At a Cafe, a Hungry Little Outsider

Dear Diary:

Last night
I joined my friends and their toddler
for a drink at a sidewalk cafe in Brooklyn.

We indulged in a large plateful
Of crispy onion rings
and a basket of fries
(ice cream for the child).

A little girl on a scooter
(no parents in sight)
wheeled over to us
and peeked at our food.

Turning the corner
she rolled up for a side view
of our bounty, surveying us as well.

Assuming her parents were nearby
and would scold her for being nosy
we did not acknowledge her.
But she kept looking.

As she devoured my fries with her dark eyes
It occurred to me that she might be hungry
or had always wanted to eat at a sidewalk cafe . . .
or had no one to mind her.

We kept eating and drinking and she rolled away.
This morning over coffee I felt terrible regret
that I did not ask her to join us
for a bowl of ice cream.

Read all recent entries and our updated submissions guidelines. Reach us via e-mail diary@nytimes.com or follow @NYTMetro on Twitter using the hashtag #MetDiary.



New York Today: Unwanted Vacation

Furloughed federal workers are restless.Robert Stolarik for The New York Times Furloughed federal workers are restless.

Picture this: You’re suddenly given two weeks off from work, maybe more.

The catch: You won’t get paid for it right away, and it’s unclear if you ever will.

This is life for about 50,000 federal employees in New York City.

We asked some at a demonstration Monday in Midtown how they’re spending their unscheduled October vacations.

“Saturday was the first time I stuck to my grocery list,” said Beverly Bratton, an I.R.S. employment-tax specialist.

On the plus side, “I got to visit my sister in Brooklyn for her birthday.”

Shawnee Swinton, a civil rights investigator for Health and Human Services, is doing free legal work for people with debt, divorces and landlord problems.

Renee Toback, a labor economist for the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, is putting away summer clothes and bringing in vegetables at her house in Yonkers. (She also finished “The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo.”)

“I’ve got to get this stuff done,” she said. “When I go back to work, I’m going to have to work evenings and weekends.”

Here’s what else you need to know for Wednesday.

WEATHER

Clouds return. High around 69. Might rain, but not till late at night.

COMMUTE

Subways: Fine so far. Click for latest status.

Rails: Fine so far. Click for L.I.R.R., Metro-North or New Jersey Transit status.

Roads: Click for traffic map or radio report on the 1s.

Alternate-side parking is suspended through tomorrow for Id al-Adha. Meters remain in effect.

COMING UP TODAY

- On the campaign trail: Joseph J. Lhota is on “Good Day New York” at 7:10 a.m., addresses the Staten Island chamber of commerce, meets with Hasidic leaders and visits a soup kitchen.

- Bill de Blasio attends a fast-food workers’ rally in Manhattan and a Muslims for de Blasio rally in Brooklyn.

- The mayor unveils a golf course at Ferry Point Park in the Bronx and announces the completion of the Manhattan portion of Water Tunnel No. 3.

- New Jersey voters will decide whether Cory A. Booker or Steve Lonegan will replace the late Senator Frank R. Lautenberg.

- Marching bands parade across the Lower East Side as the Honk NYC fest gets rowdy. 6:30 p.m. [Free, location to be disclosed later today]

- Sing songs about subways (and other things) to a live karaoke band at the Transit Museum in Brooklyn, where an exhibit of subway-themed album covers is up. 6 to 9 p.m. [$10]

- Movies about sloths, rhinos, baboons and elephants at the Wildlife Conservation Film Festival near Lincoln Center. 6 and 8:30 p.m. [$20]

- For more events, see The New York Times Arts & Entertainment guide.

IN THE NEWS

- Mr. de Blasio ditched the traditional frontrunner’s playbook and attacked Mr. Lhota relentlessly in their first televised debate. [New York Times]

- Casino opponents took a sledgehammer to a slot machine outside the Capitol in Albany. [New York Times]

- The manager of a library on Staten Island didn’t read a book until she was 10. [New York Times]

- Scoreboard: Islanders lose to Sabres, 4-3.

Sandra E. Garcia contributed reporting.

New York Today is a morning roundup that stays live from 6 a.m. till about noon.

What would you like to see here to start your day? Post a comment, e-mail us at nytoday@nytimes.com or reach us via Twitter using #NYToday.

Find us on weekdays at nytoday.com.