Ray Mickshaw/Fox Zooey Deschanel and Jake Johnson in last weekâs episode of âNew Girlâ on Fox. Previously we heard from the creators of âModern Family,â âHomelandâ and âJustified.â
Last week Foxâs âNew Girlâ effectively ended any will-they-or-wonât-they chatter about the flirty roommates played by Zooey Descanel and Jake Johnson (they did). This week, Elizabeth Meriwether, the seriesâs creator and show runner, addresses concerns that she ruined the show in the process.
âOh no! Youâre right! It was too soon! I messed up,â she writes (joking).
Ms. Meriwether, a veteran of New Yorkâs downtown theater scene who has also written movies like âNo Strings Attached,â responded to questions from Times readers about âNew Girl.â Below, in addition to parsing the mechanics of The Kiss, she reveals her favorite scenes for each character, where to find the rules for âTrue American,â the showâs convoluted drinking game, and which of the often outlandish Schmidt plot lines were actually based in reality.
Q.
Why, oh why, did you go down the Jess and Nick road Everyone knew the attraction was always there under the sur! face, but now that they kissed, it is going to be so awkward. - Mnoelle, New York
A.
Oh no! Youâre right! It was too soon! I messed up. What should I do now Maybe I can make that episode into an elaborate dream sequence.
Josh Haner/The New York Times Elizabeth Meriwether. But seriously folks. Iâve found that the kiss has actually invigorated the show and the characters. As opposed to letting the tension out, itâs added spark and conflict and helped us focus. Itâs been fun to write the aftermath, and I know the actors are having fun with the new dynamics. Itâs not going to lead to immediate happiness for everyone, if thatâs what youâre worried abut. Donât you find, in real life, that kissing leads to more comedic situations not less I like awkwardness. âNew Girlâ thrives on awkwardness. But I hope you keep watching. Donât give up on us yet. We might actually figure it out.
Q.
Just give me some reassurance: Please donât make Nick and Jess the new âRoss and Rachelâ (the comparison is running rampant in the blogs). - Amanda, South Carolina
A.
I think Nick is going to be the new Rachel, and Jess is going to be the new Ross. Women everywhere are going to be asking their hairstylists for âThe Nick.â If weâre keeping score, Schmidt is obviously Monica, and Winston is a sort of Chandler/Phoebe hybrid, if such a thing can exist. Cece is George Clooneyâs character from âERâ mixed with the neighbor on âHome Improvement.â
Q.
Hi Liz, just a question about ! filming t! he kiss of Nick and Jess: did you tell them how to kiss, like with the small pecks in the end or did they just improvise, like they felt for their characters to be right at that moment - Newgirlfangirl, Germany
A.
Embarrassingly, I actually did try to tell them how to kiss. I walked up to Jake Johnson between takes and said: âI want you to kind of take her, and then do thisâ"â (I demonstrated by making my fingers kiss each other) âThen wait and do that again, but kind of like thisâ"â (more finger kissing). He just stared at me for a beat, and then, to his credit, nodded and said, âI think I got it.â
Giving actors direction on how to kiss or have sex on camera can be deeply absurd. Iâll never forget watching Ivan Reitman explain how many thrusts the actors were supposed to do in the sex scene in âNo Strings Attached.â The truth is, anything that physial is like a dance routine, it requires precision and timing, and both actors need to know what goes where when. The challenge is waiting to giggle until your hand is in front of your face, and you can pass it off as coughing.
Q.
Is Schmidtâs casual racism ever going to be addressed I know that itâs meant for edgy laughs, but it seems particularly more offensive this season. - Kerissa Ward, New York, NY
A.
I know. Iâm sorry. Iâm going to try and get him to shut up, but he can be such a jerk. I apologize on his behalf for any offense heâs caused. He also makes fun of women, fat people, poor people, Jewish people, and the movie âThe Hobbitâ if that helps at all.
Adam Taylor/FOX Max Greenfield as Schmidt. Q.
Is there any chance of you telling us Schmidtâs first name - Jamie, NY
A.
Unfortunately, the word is unprintable in The New York Times.
Q.
You had a rather successful career as an off-Broadway actress and playwright (âHeddatron,â Mistakes Madeline Made). Has your experience in New Yorkâs downtown theater scene prepared you for life in Hollywood and as the creator of a successful TV show And if so, how - Mr. Frazier, Harlem, NY
A.
Please god, I hope my experience in downtown theater isnât over, because Iâd love to keep making weird plays. I canât wait for Charles Isherwood to call my next play âsi-com-yâ and tell me to stick to writing television. But, yes, I learned everything working in theater. I learned the importance of community â" I was constantly going to play readings, stand-up nights, improv nights. I went to one of the earliest workshops of âGatzâ by the Elevator Repair Service. I sat through a seven-hour play at Lincoln Center that was entirely in French and mostly performed on skateboards. I got to work with incredible people (Alex Timbers, Evan Cabnet, Sam Gold, Marsha Norman, Chris Durang, Jenny Gersten, Naked Angels, Ars Nova), and my work got better by proximity to all of the energy, weirdness, and insanity. Now, whenever I feel stuck, I try to get out of my own head and go see something new. Laugh at someone elseâs jokes. Open myself up to the artists around me. It makes it less hard. So thatâs one of the things I learned in New York. (âThe Things I Lea! rned In N! ew Yorkâ sounds like a bad one-woman show actually. I hope I never write that.)
Q.
Zooey Deschanel is great. would your show have succeeded without her or, to put it another way, did you find yourself shaping the show around her personality Also, how much of the tone of the show did you pick up among fellow students while at Yale - ponsoldt, athens, georgia
Patrick McElhenney/FOX Ms. Deschanel in the episode âCabin.â A.
Would the show succeed without Zooey Thatâs easy. Hell no. The character and the actress have merged together in a great way, and Zooeyâs spirit and talent are absolutely at the heart of everything we do. (And hi, Mr. Ponsold.. Good to hear from you.)
Q.
Are there any particular female comedians who inspired you when you created Jessâs role - Hannah, New York, NY
A.
While I was trying to figure out what the show was going to be, I fell down a Hulu Hole with this British series (or should I say âprogrammeâ), âGreen Wing.â Procrastination Yes. But I just fell in love with the lead actress Tamsin Greig (who now stars in Episodes on Showtime). Itâs an amazing show â" hugely broad physical comedy, commedia dell arte, mixed with real characters, real emotion, and a great love triangle. I was very much inspired by that character and the crazy tonal shifts the show pulled off. Why do British people make such good TV Itâs so annoying. Stop it. Is it because they have free health care Uggh.
Also Diane Keaton. Sheâs so massively, heart-wrenchingly funny, and she is never just pl! aying one! thing. Whenever we get criticized that the Jess character is too this or too that, I think about Diane Keaton. Funny women arenât feminist symbols. Funny women are honest women. I guess thatâs also true for men, but no one ever asks me if my male characters are presenting a negative image of masculinity. (As if that were possible⦠men are AMAZING.)
Q.
I absolutely love your show! It reveals so much about the culture of young adults that I wouldnât otherwise know, since I am a 70 year old grandmother of three. The only question I have is how much is script driven and how much comes from your amazing cast memberâs contributions - SeniorSues, Minneapolis, MN
A.
Thatâs so good to hear. You just warmed my cold comedy writerâs heart. Thank you so much.
And to answer your question, we have a really loose set. We shoot extra jokes that we call âalts.â The actors, who are all great on their feet, build on those extra jokes or jst riff on the ideas that are in the scene. The âalt packâ is a thick packet of extra jokes for that dayâs work that our tireless, ridiculously talented writing staff slave away on and hate with a passion. When itâs all cooking, the collaborative, anything-goes energy of set translates to the screen and makes it feel real and alive.
The trouble with making a single camera comedy (a comedy that doesnât have a laugh track and isnât performed in front of a studio audience) is that youâre forced to make a judgment call if something is funny based only on your instincts instead of actual laughter. The playwright in me wishes we were performing the show live, because I could hear if something was working or not. But my experience sitting in audiences and listening to real laughs (and horrible silences) has been helpful in the editing room. My co-showrunners, Dave Finkel and Brett Baer have worked on everything from âAnimaniacsâ to âUnited States of Taraâ to â30 Rockâ and Ste! ve Welch,! our editor, is a wizard of comedic pacing. Between all of us, we try to figure it out. But there are some real stinkers in there too. What can you do Just keep trying. If youâre lucky, you get to make twenty-four episodes a season and completely stop sleeping or showering. Unfortunately, one continues to eat.
Q.
Is it more important for you to adapt for the voice of the actor or stay strong to the voice of the character - Alex Tucci, Oakville Ontario
A.
When I was talking to Jake Kasdan about directing the pilot, one of the first things he said was to cast actors that I love and write towards their strengths. He told me not to be precious with the characters Iâd created in the pilot â" on a television show running for years, the character and the actor start to fuse into one thing, and if youâre constantly fighting what the actor naturally does or trying to shoehorn the wrong person into some dream of the character in your head, you wil end up with a bad show. He was right. Our scripts are important, but I think the most important thing is whatâs happening on set â" whatâs working or not working with the actors. Our actors are very much a part of the creative process, not joke-reciting robots. (Although, Iâve actually written for a joke-reciting robot in âHeddatron,â and that had its own joys.)
Q.
The striking thing about âNew Girlâ is that under all the comedy, thereâs something about the emotions and reactions that feels very real â" much more real than other sitcoms. Like â" maybe everybody is sort of laid bare in different ways. Was this the plan for the show To make it a completely different type of comedy - JL, Chapel Hill
A.
Yes, that was the hope, but Jake Kasdan brought that tone (or âvibeâ as we say in California) to the show. He blended comedy and! emotion ! beautifully on âFreaks and Geeks,â and that was one of the main reasons I wanted him to direct the pilot so badly. Itâs a tough tone to maintain though, and we struggle with it all the time. Weâre lucky to have actors and writers who can find the real emotion under the stupidest joke, and find stupid jokes in the most emotional scenes. Our show works best when youâre laughing, but youâre a little sad about it. Youâre welcome, America.
Q.
One of my favorite episodes this season is âModels,â where we saw flashbacks of the history of friendships of Nick/Schmidt and Jess/Cece. Will we get more episodes like that - Carl, The Philippines
A.
We actually have an episode coming up that celebrates the ten-year anniversary of Nick and Schmidt living together as roommates " their tin anniversary. This came from a passing reference in âModelsâ we thought would make a funny episode. So we did it. None of the characters are related, so itâs been important to see their histories in flashbacks. These are probably my favorite things to write on the show.
Greg Gayne/FOX From left, Jake Johnson, Max Greenfield and Lamorne Morris. Q.
At what point in our nationâs racial consciousness-raising will Winston get to carry an A-plot - Kate Ryan, Cary, NC
A.
Yeeeeesh. Okay. He has been in A-stories, but point taken. Lamorne Morris is fantastic, and we all love writing for him.
Q.
! Iâve he! ard/read that Jess is based on Zooey, but what about other characters (Iâm basically asking if thereâs a real-life version of Schmidt.) - Jemi, Edmonton
A.
There was no one âSchmidtâ in my life when I first wrote the character, but since then, Iâve heard a bunch of stories about real-life Schmidtâs. Which makes me both sad and happy. My favorite real-life Schmidt stories come from my friend Mark in London. In the Season Two premiere, Schmidt throws himself a âre-branding partyâ and that actually came from a true story Mark told me about his friend. God love him.
Q.
What is the one scene that you would say is your âfavoriteâ I know that sounds boring but if you were forced to pick one scene at gunpoint â" I donât know why someone so violent would make you ever choose a favorite âNew Girlâ scene â" which would be the scene youâre proudest of - Sarah, alligator pit
A.
Itâs funny to imagie a situation where someone is holding me at gunpoint and asking me that question. Like a very strange, unpopular episode of âLaw and Order: SVU.â
Okay, by character. For Jess: The scene in âBad in Bedâ when she chokes Justin Long as he does a sexy Jimmy Stewart impression. For Nick: The scene in âMenziesâ when he slowly opens up to the old Asian man on the bench and ends up telling him that heâs afraid of dying. For Winston: The scene in âSecretsâ when he gets rid of Nickâs sorority girls by doing a monologue as his alter ego Theodore K. Mullins. For Cece: The scene in âFancyman Part Twoâ when she admits she has feelings for Schmidt while naked in the back of Winstonâs car. For Schmidt: The scene in âEggsâ where he explains his methods for pleasuring women to Sadie, the lesbian gynecologist. So there. Please donât shoot.
Q.
My question for you is mostly related to costume designs and fashion. Are you aware of the many websites that! search t! o find exact or close to matches for Zoeâs on set wardrobe How do you pick the clothes for these characters- are they dictated by vendors of the actors personal styles - BillieRose, Long Island, NY
A.
Deb McGuire is our unbelievably talented costume designer. She designed the costumes for all ten years of âFriendsâ (which means sheâs responsible for some terrible fashion choices I made in high school â" a lot of baby-tees and vests). Zooey obviously has a fantastic sense of style and innovative taste, and the two of them cook it all up. I wear pajamas and sweatpants every day and try to stay out of the way. I think my personal style has inspired a lot of Nick Millerâs outfits.
Q.
We are hardcore âNew Girlâ nerds and we were wondering if you ever plan on going more in depth with the game âTrue American.â Like maybe a bok of rules or more footage of a game played or just a way for us to make it as legitimate as possible. Weâre pretty darn serious about this. I mean, weâre planning customized bowling shirts for our pro True American team. - Christina & Amanda, Florida Panhandle
A.
Thatâs amazing. I love you guys. Weâll work on some rules for you, but I would just trust your hearts, get really wasted, and look inside yourselves. I think youâll find the rules were there all along.
Thank you for sending in questions. I was really excited and moved by the opportunity to talk directly with our audience. Keep watching. Weâll get better, I promise.